FoodReference.com Logo

FoodReference.com   (Since 1999)
 

Food Articles, News & Features Section

Home       Food Articles       Food Trivia       Today in Food History       Recipes       Cooking Tips       Videos       Food Quotes       Who's Who       Food Trivia Quizzes       Crosswords       Food Poems       Cookbooks       Food Posters       Recipe Contests       Culinary Schools       Gourmet Tours       Food Festivals & Shows

  You are here > 

HomeFood ArticlesFish & Seafood >  Salmon, Wild or Farmed

 

CULINARY SCHOOLS &
COOKING CLASSES

From Amateur & Basic Cooking Classes to Professional Chef Training
Over 1,000 schools & classes listed for U.S., Online & Worldwide

Culinary Posters and Food Art

See also: Salmon Facts ; Sockeye Salmon ; Salmon Recipes

SALMON: FARMED vs WILD

 

EarthTalk®
From the Editors of E/The Environmental Magazine

Dear EarthTalk: What are the differences between farmed versus wild salmon when it comes to human and environmental health?
-- Greg Diamond, Nashville, TN (8/29/10)

Salmon farming, which involves raising salmon in containers placed under water near shore, began in Norway about 50 years ago and has since caught on in the U.S., Ireland, Canada, Chile and the United Kingdom. Due to the large decline in wild fish from overfishing, many experts see the farming of salmon and other fish as the future of the industry. On the flip side, many marine biologists and ocean advocates fear such a future, citing serious health and ecological implications with so-called “aquaculture.”

George Mateljan, founder of Health Valley Foods, says that farmed fish are “far inferior” to their wild counterparts. “Despite being much fattier, farmed fish provide less usable beneficial omega 3 fats than wild fish,” he says. Indeed, U.S. Department of Agriculture research bears out that the fat content of farmed salmon is 30-35 percent by weight while wild salmons’ fat content is some 20 percent lower, though with a protein content about 20 percent higher. And farm-raised fish contain higher amounts of pro-inflammatory omega 6 fats instead of the preponderance of healthier omega 3s found in wild fish.

Salmon Farm
Photo: Sam Beebe, EcoTrust.
Ocean advocates would like to end fish farming and instead put resources into reviving wild fish populations. Pictured: a salmon farming operation in Chile.

“Due to the feedlot conditions of aquafarming, farm-raised fish are doused with antibiotics and exposed to more concentrated pesticides than their wild kin,” reports Mateljan. He adds that farmed salmon are given a salmon-colored dye in their feed “without which their flesh would be an unappetizing grey color.”

Some aquaculture proponents claim that fish farming eases pressure on wild fish populations, but most ocean advocates disagree. To wit, one National Academy of Sciences study found that sea lice from fish farming operations killed up to 95 percent of juvenile wild salmon migrating past them. And two other studies—one in western Canada and the other in England—found that farmed salmon accumulate more cancer-causing PCBs and dioxins than wild salmon due to pesticides circulating in the ocean that get absorbed by the sardines, anchovies and other fish that are ground up as feed for the fish farms. A recent survey of U.S. grocery stores found that farmed salmon typically contains 16 times the PCBs found in wild salmon; other studies in Canada, Ireland and Great Britain reached similar conclusions.

Another problem with fish farms is the liberal use of drugs and antibiotics to control bacterial outbreaks and parasites. These primarily synthetic chemicals spread out into marine ecosystems just from drifting in the water column as well as from fish feces. In addition, millions of farmed fish escape fish farms every year around the world and mix into wild populations, spreading contaminants and disease accordingly.

Ocean advocates would like to end fish farming and instead put resources into reviving wild fish populations. But given the size of the industry, improving conditions would be a start. Noted Canadian environmentalist David Suzuki says that aquaculture operations could use fully enclosed systems that trap waste and do not allow farmed fish to escape into the wild ocean. As for what consumers can do, Suzuki recommends buying only wild-caught salmon and other fish. Whole Foods and other natural foods and high end grocers, as well as concerned restaurants, will stock wild salmon from Alaska and elsewhere.

Earth Talk

CONTACTS: Health Valley Foods, www.healthvalley.com; USDA, www.usda.gov; David Suzuki Foundation, www.davidsuzuki.org 

SEND YOUR ENVIRONMENTAL QUESTIONS TO: EarthTalk, P.O. Box 5098, Westport, CT 06881; earthtalk@emagazine.com    Read past columns at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalk/archives.php. EarthTalk is now a book! Details and order information at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalkbook 
 

TOP 

RELATED ARTICLES

Tilefish :History & Facts       Asian Carp Become A Major Problem       World Fisheries In Crises       Swai Fish (Pangasius)       Alaskan Wild Black Cod       Amberjack       Aquaculture Production & the Environment       Bighead Carp       Bluefish       Catch Shares Fisheries Management       Catfish, Farm Raised       Caviar From Russia with Love       Caviar: Description & Facts       Cod: British Gold       Cyanide Fishing       Fish Facts & Health Benefits       Fish Farms: Raising Fish on Inland 'Farms'       Fish, Becoming More Expensive by the Day       Fish, Something Fishy Going On Here       Flounder       Grouper       Jellyfish       King Mackerel       King Salmon       Komoci Konbu, Herring Eggs on Kelp       Mackerel, Wild      Mahi-Mahi       Mullet       Pompano       Ocean Fisheries & Overfishing       Salmon, Wild or Farmed       Salmon of Wisdom       Salmon Facts & Types       Salmon, Wild Salmon & Dams       Sockeye Salmon Record Run       Shark       Shark Finning       Smoked Fish       Snapper       Spanish Mackerel       Striped Bass       Sushi Fact Sheet       Swordfish       Tilapia Description & Facts       Tilapia: Grilling Perfect Tilapia       Trout: Fit for a King       Trout In Trouble       Atlantic Bluefin Tuna in Trouble       Tuna on the Grill       Yellowfin Tuna       Whales Still Hunted in 2012

 

   Home        About Us & Contact Us        Cooking Contests        Free Magazines        Food Links  
Copyright notice

 

 

 

POPULAR PAGES

FREE Food & Beverage Publications
An extensive selection of free magazines and other publications for qualified Food, Beverage & Hospitality professionals